A comparison of the surgical outcomes of ventriculoperitoneal versus lumbar peritoneal shunts in the management of intracranial hypertension secondary to cryptococcal meningitis in HIV infected adult patients.

OBJECTIVE: Cryptococcal meningitis (CM), an AIDS-defining illness, significantly impacts morbidity and mortality. This study aims to compare complications arising from ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS) and lumbar peritoneal shunt (LPS) procedures used to manage refractory intracranial hypertension (IH) secondary to CM in HIV-infected patients.

METHODS: Retrospective data were collected from January 2003 to January 2015 for HIV-infected adults diagnosed with refractory IH secondary to CM and subsequently shunted. Demographics, clinical characteristics, antiretroviral therapy, laboratory findings (including CD4 count and CSF results), CT brain scan results, shunt-related complications, and mortality were compared between VPS and LPS groups.

RESULTS: This study included 83 patients, with 60 (72%) undergoing VPS and 23 (28%) receiving LPS. Mean ages were comparable between VPS (32.5) and LPS (32.2) groups (p = 0.89). Median CD4+ counts were 76 cells/µl (IQR= 30-129) in VPS versus 54 cells/µl (IQR= 31-83) in LPS (p=0.45). VPS group showed a higher mean haemoglobin of 11.5 g/dl compared to 9.9 g/dl in the LPS group (p=0.001). CT brain scans showed hydrocephalus in 55 VPS and 13 LPS patients respectively. Shunt complications were observed in 17 (28%) VPS patients versus 10 (43.5%) LPS patients (p=0.5). Patients developing shunt sepsis in the VPS group exhibited a median CD4+ count of 117 cells/µl (IQR= 76-129) versus 48 cells/µl (IQR= 31- 66) in the LPS group (p=0.03). Early shunt malfunction occurred more frequently in the LPS group compared to VPS group (p=0.044). The mean hospital stay was 6.2 days for VPS versus 5.4 days for LPS patients (p=0.9). In-hospital mortality was 6%, occurring in three VPS and two LPS patients respectively.

CONCLUSION: Shunting procedures remain important surgical interventions for refractory IH secondary to HIV-related CM. However, cautious consideration is warranted for patients with CD4 counts below 200 cells/µL due to increased shunt complications. This study suggests a trend toward higher complication rates in patients undergoing LPS insertion.