Prevention of sclerosis around cannulated screw after treatment of femoral neck fractures with bioceramic nails: a finite element analysis.

PURPOSE: Conventional cannulated screws (CS) are the main treatment method for femoral neck fractures (FNF). However, the rate of femoral head necrosis remains high after FNF treatment. The study aimed to compare the biomechanical features of different internal fixation materials for the treatment of Pauwel type III FNF to explore new strategies for clinical management.

METHODS: A new material was prepared by applying casting, freeze drying and sintering process. The independently developed calcium magnesium silicate ceramic powder and hydrogel solution were evenly mixed to obtain a high-viscosity bio-ink, and a bioceramic nail (BN) with high mechanical strength and high fracture toughness was successfully prepared. Four internal fixations were developed to establish the Pauwel type III FNF and healed fracture finite element models: A, three CSs; B, three BNs; C, two BNs and one CS; D, one BN and two CSs. Von Mises stress and displacement of the implants and femur were observed.

RESULTS: The measured Mg content in ceramic powder was 2.08 wt%. The spectral data confirmed that the ceramic powder has high crystallinity, which coincides with the wollastonite-2 M (PDF# 27-0088). The maximum von Mises stresses for the four models were concentrated in the lower part of the fracture surface, at 318.42 Mpa, 103.52 MPa, 121.16 MPa, and 144.06 MPa in models A, B, C, and D, respectively. Moreover, the maximum Von-mises stresses of the implants of the four models were concentrated near the fracture end at 243.65 MPa (A) and 58.02 MPa (B), 102.18 MPa (C), and 144.06 MPa (D). The maximum displacements of the four models were 5.36 mm (A), 3.41 mm (B), 3.60 mm (C), and 3.71 mm (D). The displacements of the three models with BNs were similar and smaller than that of the triple CS fracture model. In the fracture healing models with and without three CSs, the greatest stress concentration was scattered among the lowest screw tail, femoral calcar region, and lateral femur shaft. The displacement and stress distributions in both models are generally consistent. The stress distribution and displacement of the three healed femoral models with BNs were essentially identical to the healing models with three CSs. The maximum von Mises stresses were 65.94 MPa (B), 64.61 MPa (C), and 66.99 MPa (D) while the maximum displacements of the three healed femoral models were 2.49 mm (B), 2.56 mm (C), and 2.49 mm (D), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS: Bioceramic nails offer greater advantages than conventional canulated screws after femoral neck fractures. However, the combination of bioceramic nails and CSs is more clinically realistic; replacing all internal fixations with bioceramic nails after the healing of femoral neck fractures can solve the problem of sclerosis formation around CSs and improve bone reconstruction by their bioactivity.