Uncoupling neurotrophic function from nociception of nerve growth factor: what can be learned from a rare human disease?

Nerve growth factor (NGF) is a powerful trophic factor that provides essential support for the survival and differentiation of sympathetic and sensory neurons during development. However, NGF also activates nociceptors contributing significantly to inflammatory pain and neuropathic pain after tissue injury. As such anti-NGF based therapies represent a promising strategy for pain management. Because of dose-dependent serious side effects such as back pain, injection site hyperalgesia, clinical trials of using NGF to treat various disorders such as diabetic neuropathies, chemotherapy-induced and human immunodeficiency virus-associated peripheral neuropathies were all discontinued. Thus far, worldwide clinical applications of NGF in treating patients are very limited except in China. Hereditary sensory autonomic neuropathy type V (HSAN V) is an extremely rare disease. Genetic analyses have revealed that HSAN V is associated with autosomal recessive mutations in NGF. One of the mutations occurred at the 100th position of mature NGF resulting in a change of residue from arginine to tryptophan (R100W). Although those HSAN V patients associated with the NGFR100W mutation suffer from severe loss of deep pain, bone fractures and joint destruction, interestingly patients with the NGFR100W mutation do not show apparent cognitive deficits, suggesting important trophic support function is preserved. We believe that NGFR100W provides an ideal tool to uncouple the two important functions of NGF: trophic versus nociceptive. Studies from investigators including ourselves have indeed confirmed in animal testing that the NGFR100W no longer induced pain. More importantly, the trophic function seemed to be largely preserved in NGF harboring the R100W mutation. On the mechanistic level, we found that the NGFR100W mutation was capable of binding to and signaling through the tyrosine receptor kinase A receptor. But its ability to bind to and activate the 75 kDa neurotrophic factor was significantly diminished. The significance of these findings is at least two folds: 1) the NGFR100W mutation can be used as an alternative to the wildtype NGF to treat human conditions without eliciting pain; and 2) the 75 kDa neurotrophic factor may serve as a novel target for pain management. We will discuss all the details in this mini-review.