A high throughput lentivirus sieving assay identifies neutralization resistant Envelope sequences and predicts in vivo sieving.

An effective prophylactic vaccine against human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) will likely require a potent antibody response that can neutralize the virus at the mucosal portal of entry. The elicitation of potent broadly-neutralizing anti-sera will be an iterative process, optimizing candidates that only block a fraction of potential viral strains. This effect, termed "sieving", is evidence of a partially efficacious vaccine. Understanding the mechanisms of resistance of the breakthrough viruses is important for improving vaccines. We developed a high-throughput assay that can be used on vaccine-elicited antisera or monoclonal antibodies. Using the SIVsmE660 swarm stock and sera from a large NHP vaccine/challenge study, our in vitro sieving assay identified the same viral subspecies as in the animal study-those with a canonical C1 amino acid variants conferring global neutralization resistance to antibodies. Using a genetically divergent swarm stock, we identified five other amino acid variants that confer global resistance; the C1 mutations in this stock were not selected, also in agreement with in vivo challenge studies. Thus, the in vitro sieving assay can be used with genetically diverse challenge stocks to predict the coverage of a vaccine-elicited sera and possibly inform candidate vaccine development efforts.