Titanium particles generated during ultrasonic scaling of implants.

BACKGROUND: There is growing concern that titanium particles may play a role in peri-implant breakdown. Ultrasonic scalers are routinely used in the debridement of peri-implant lesions. This in vitro study is designed to evaluate if titanium particles are produced when an ultrasonic scaler is used on an implant.

METHODS: New sandblasted, large grit, acid etched (SLA) coated implants were subjected to ultrasonic scaling with stainless steel, titanium, and PEEK plastic tips. The implants were placed in a holding device and the ultrasonic scaler was positioned on the SLA surface under 25 grams of pressure. The implants were subjected to 30 scaling motions. The ultrasonic coolant water was collected and the number of metallic particles were counted under a light microscope. The particles were confirmed to be titanium via elemental analysis. The implants were visually evaluated for damage to the SLA coating.

RESULTS: No metallic particles were detected in the water supplied to the ultrasonic scalers (passive control). Metallic particles were detected when implants were subjected to the ultrasonic coolant water only without the scaler tip touching the implant (active control). All implants that were scaled produced metallic particles and showed easily detectable damage to the SLA layer.

CONCLUSION: All ultrasonic scaling caused the production of titanium particles and caused damage to the SLA coating of the implant. Ultrasonic scalers should be used with great caution in the treatment of peri-implant conditions and care should be taken to not touch the SLA surface of the implant. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.