Outcomes after surgical resection of lower eyelid tumors and reconstruction using a nasal chondromucosal graft and an upper eyelid myocutaneous flap.

INTRODUCTION: Surgical excision of large malignant lower eyelid tumors may cause important full-thickness eyelid defects. The reconstruction of such defects must restore the physiologic function of the eyelid and also re-establish an acceptable aesthetic result.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: We report the outcomes of full-thickness excision of tumors extending over half of the horizontal lid length, followed by reconstruction using a nasal chondromucosal graft (coming from the ipsilateral ala of the nose) and an upper eyelid myocutaneous flap. Histological analysis of the specimen identified the tumor type and surgical margins for each patient.

RESULTS: A total of 25 patients were operated using this reconstruction technique between March 2009 and June 2015: 17 basal cell carcinomas, 3 spindle cell carcinomas and 5 conjunctival melanomas (out of which 2 were associated with lentigo maligna). Mean duration of follow-up after surgery was respectively 36, 41 and 17 months for each of these 3 tumor types. We found a single local tumor recurrence and this was a basal cell carcinoma in a xeroderma pigmentosum patient. After surgery, none of the patients had lagophthalmos or ocular surface complications. Only 4 patients had a 1mm scleral show postoperatively; 3 other patients developed a small retraction of the eyelid after adjuvant radiotherapy and a 1mm scleral show occurred.

CONCLUSION: In malignant tumors, complete surgical excision with histological margins adapted to tumor type prevents local recurrence in most cases. Our repair strategy of nasal chondromucosal graft and skin-muscle flap for large inferior eyelid defects provides good functional and aesthetic results.