Treatment of recurrent anterior shoulder instability with the Latarjet or Bristow procedure in older patients.

BACKGROUND: The coracoid transfer procedure is commonly and successfully used to treat shoulder instability in young patients. However, there is concern that the outcome of this procedure might be inferior in older patients because of decreased bone graft quality and the potential concomitant presence of irreparable rotator cuff tears (RCTs).

METHODS: All patients older than 40 years treated with a coracoid transfer procedure between 1998 and 2013 because of anterior shoulder instability were included. Surgical indication criteria were anterior glenoid bone defects and/or the presence of an irreparable yet functionally compensated RCT. Of 27 consecutive patients, 25 (93%) were followed up after an average of 9 years (2-15 years) clinically as well as by means of computed tomography scans. Mean age at surgery was 62 years (40-85 years).

RESULTS: Nine patients (36%) were revised during the follow-up period. The average Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index of the nonrevised patients was 556; Rowe score, 77; American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score, 75; Constant score, 65; and subjective shoulder value, 70%. The average preoperative instability arthropathy score of 0.7 increased to 2.0 (P < .001). An irreparable RCT showed no significant effect on the clinical outcome scores or revision rate but was associated with the development of cuff arthropathy (R = 0.89; P = .01). An increased grade of preoperative cuff arthropathy was associated with a higher revision rate (R = 0.55; P = .04).

CONCLUSION: The coracoid transfer procedure represents a joint-preserving treatment option for anterior shoulder instability in older patients with glenoid bone defects or concomitant irreparable yet functionally compensated RCTs. However, bone graft- and hardware-related complications as well as required revision operations are frequent.