Relationship Between Periodontal Screening and Recording Index Scores and Need for Periodontal Access Surgery.

BACKGROUND: The validity of using pretreatment Periodontal Screening and Recording (PSR) index sextant scores to estimate periodontal access surgery needs is evaluated in patients with chronic periodontitis before and after completion of non-surgical periodontal therapy.

METHODS: In 110 adults, pretreatment probing data identified 486 sextants with PSR scores of 4 and 125 sextants with PSR scores of 3. Periodontal access surgery needs for all sextants were determined prior to treatment and after completion of non-surgical periodontal therapy for 213 sextants in 38 patients by two experienced periodontist examiners.

RESULTS: PSR scores of 4 identified untreated sextants with periodontal access surgery needs significantly better than PSR scores of 3 (odds ratio = 27.8; P <0.001) in multilevel, mixed-effects, logistic regression modeling analysis. However, only 37.6% of sextants with both pretreatment PSR scores of 4 and a pretreatment periodontal access surgery need continued to have surgical access needs after completion of non-surgical periodontal therapy. A higher percentage of sextants with PSR scores of 4 or 3 revealed periodontal access surgical needs when Class II or III furcation involvements and/or Grade II or III tooth mobility were also detected in the sextant than when these parameters were not detected.

CONCLUSIONS: Pretreatment PSR index scores of 4 were a strong indicator of periodontal access surgery needs in untreated dentition sextants but markedly overestimated surgical access needs remaining after completion of non-surgical periodontal therapy. These findings raise questions about the usefulness of pretreatment PSR evaluations for estimating potential periodontal access surgery needs in patients to be initially treated with non-surgical periodontal therapy.