Stability of chemically available fluoride in Chilean toothpastes.

BACKGROUND: Storage time may reduce the amount of soluble fluoride (F) in toothpastes. Although we previously studied the type and concentration of F in fresh samples of commercial Chilean toothpastes, their stability was not determined.

AIM: To evaluate the stability of soluble F in Chilean toothpastes after 1 year of storage.

DESIGN: All the toothpastes (n = 30) previously used were re-analyzed after 1 year of storage time at room temperature (±22°C). Total F (TF = soluble F + insoluble F) and total soluble F (TSF = F ion + MFP ion) were assessed using an ion-specific electrode, through a validated methodology. Data were expressed in ppm of F (mg F/kg).

RESULTS: Mean (±SD; n = 30) TF and TSF concentrations after storage were 1049 ± 427 and 987 ± 411 ppm F, respectively. Five toothpastes showed between 30% and 50% of insoluble F, four of them formulated with MFP/calcium-based abrasive. In two products, there was a reduction in TSF below the evidence-based anticaries effectiveness threshold of 1000 ppm F.

CONCLUSIONS: Although most of the toothpastes tested kept their original TSF content after 1 year of storage, some products evidenced an important reduction, which may compromise their anticaries efficacy. Reductions in TSF may be explained by an incorrect F salt-abrasive formulation.