Radionuclide Salivagram and Gastroesophageal Reflux Scintigraphy in Pediatric Patients: Targeting Different Types of Pulmonary Aspiration.

OBJECTIVE: Both gastroesophageal reflux (GER) scintigraphy and radionuclide salivagram are commonly used in the detection of pulmonary aspiration in pediatric patients. This investigation is to compare the diagnostic value of these 2 imaging methods.

METHODS: This retrospective study included 4186 pediatric patients (aged 1 week to 16 years; mean age, 28 months) who underwent a GER scintigraphy and/or radionuclide salivagram. Detection rate of pulmonary aspiration by the 2 imaging techniques was compared.

RESULTS: The detection rate for pulmonary aspiration in patients undergoing both procedures was 1.9% (5 of 266) for GER scintigraphy and 22.2% (59 of 266) for radionuclide salivagram. Fifty-six of 59 patients with proven aspiration on radionuclide salivagram demonstrated no such findings on GER scintigraphy, whereas 2 of 5 patients with proven aspiration on GER scintigraphy demonstrated no such findings on radionuclide salivagram. In patients who underwent only 1 procedure (either GER scintigraphy or salivagram), the detection rate for pulmonary aspiration was 0.4% (15 of 3551) for GER scintigraphy and 20.3% (75 of 369) for radionuclide salivagram.

CONCLUSIONS: Radionuclide salivagram showed a much higher detection rate for pulmonary aspiration compared with GER scintigraphy. However, this may be related to a significantly higher prevalence of antegrade versus retrograde aspiration in our study population. Our results also suggest that not all episodes of retrograde aspiration can be detected by a radionuclide salivagram, and the requested scan should be tailored to the type of suspected aspiration.