[Re-evaluation of the AOK hospital navigator with a focus on total knee replacement].

BACKGROUND: One of the biggest health insurance companies in Germany (AOK, Allgemeine Ortskrankenkasse) has published new results focussing on process quality of total knee replacement in 2010. These results were published in the online portal "Weiße Liste", which is based on health insurance routine data. The German Association of Orthopeadic Surgery questions the credibility of the rating system of the "Weiße Liste". To prove the system an interdisciplinary task force was created.

MATERIAL AND METHODS: The task force identified patient-specific parameters, which influence the outcome of total knee replacement based on the literature and expert opinions. Out of 907 orthopaedic departments, 4 above average and four below average were identified. The AOK was asked to provide 80 data sets for each department. These anonymised data sets could be converted into patient-specific data sets in the identified departments. Statistical analysis was performed to answer the question of whether there are differences between the below and the above average groups.

RESULTS: 625 cases could be investigated. We found an increased rate of postoperative complications in the below average group. There are differences between both groups in terms of factors influencing the procedure. In the below average group an increased rate of patients with one or more comorbidities and a preoperative extension lag of over 10° was found. The above average group has a higher rate of operations before the knee replacement.

CONCLUSION: The results need to be proven on a larger scale. Further, prospective investigations are planned.