Assessment of morphology, antigenicity, and nucleic acid integrity for diagnostic thyroid pathology using formalin substitute fixatives.

BACKGROUND: With the advent of the formaldehyde standard law in France, and because of the impact of new methods for diagnosis and prognosis in pathology, formalin replacement in surgical pathology laboratories is currently being discussed in France. However, a set of criteria must be assessed before introducing a formalin substitute fixative. The objective of this study was to compare formalin substitute fixation with formalin fixation and cryoconservation of tissues from several benign and malignant thyroid pathologies with respect to morphology, antigenicity, and nucleic acid (RNA, DNA, microRNA) integrity.

METHODS: Calibrated specimens (200 mg, 1 cm(2) each) from four conventional papillary thyroid carcinomas, four follicular variant of papillary thyroid carcinomas, three minimally invasive follicular carcinomas, four thyroid adenomas, five thyroid nodular hyperplasias, and five normal thyroid tissues were fixed for 6, 12, or 24 hours, in different fixatives (formalin, Glyo-Fixx, FineFIX, ExcellPlus, RCL2) at room temperature or at 4 degrees C. Tissues were stained (hematoxylin-eosin, periodic acid Schiff, trichromic Masson, and Sweet-Gordon staining) and their antigenicity determined by immunohistochemistry (performed with HBME-1, galectin-3, CK19, vimentin, CD31, and KL1 antibodies). Evaluation by four pathologists was made blinded. The quantity and quality of DNA, RNA, and two representative microRNA extracted from deparaffinized sections of paraffin embedded specimen were compared with that of cryosections.

RESULTS: The staining and morphology were not altered by the use of different fixatives. However, formalin, FineFIX, and RCL2 gave the best results for immunohistochemistry. Moreover, FineFIX and RCL2 gave the highest amount of nucleic acids and of the best quality.

CONCLUSIONS: All the formalin substitute fixatives used in this study provided good histomorphologic quality for the different stained thyroid tissues, but individually, some fixatives performed better for immunohistochemical and molecular biological procedures for different thyroid pathologies.